CoP11 Decisions on Amendment Proposals

Proposal No. & Species / Taxon	Proponent(s)	Action proposed	CoP 11 Decision *
Prop. 11.1 Ceropegia spp. Lantern Flowers	SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.2 Frerea indica	SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.3 Byblis spp. Rainbow Plant	AUSTRALIA	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.4 Disocactus macdougallii MacDougall's Cactus	SWITZERLAND	Transfer from App.I to App.II	ACCEPTED (VOTE 67 / 25)
Prop. 11.5 Sclerocactus mariposensis Lloyd's Mariposa Cactus	SWITZERLAND	Transfer from App.I to App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 47 / 35)
Prop. 11.6 Cephalotus follicularis Albany Pitcher Plant	AUSTRALIA	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.7 Dudleya stolonifera, Dudleya traskiae Laguna Beach Liveforever Santa Barbara Liveforever	SWITZERLAND	Transfer from App.I to App.II	ACCEPTED as amended (Dudleya traskiae remains in App.I) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.8 Cyatheaceae spp. Dicksoniaceae spp. Tree ferns	SWITZERLAND	Change listings of Cyatheaceae spp. to Cyathea spp. + change listings of Dicksoniaceae spp. to Dicksonia spp. (originating in America) and Cibotium barometz	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.9 Shortia galacifolia O'conee-Bells	SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	(WITHDRAWN)
Prop. 11.10 Lewisia cotyledon, L. maguirei, L. serrata Siskiyou Lewisia, Maguire's Bitter-root, Saw-toothed Lewisia	SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED as amended (Lewisia maguirei and L.serrata remain in App.II) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.11 Darlingtonia californica California Pitcherplant	SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.12 Crocodylus niloticus Nile Crocodile	TANZANIA	Maintain in App.II + annual export quota of 1600	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.13 Manis crassicaudata, M. pentadactyla, M. javanica Indian Pangolin, Chinese Pangolin, Malayan Pangolin	INDIA, NEPAL, SRI LANKA, USA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED as amended (maintain in App.II with a zero quota for trade in wild specimen for commercial purposes) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.14 Tursiops truncatus ponticus Black Sea Bottlenose Dolphin	GEORGIA, USA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN (actions to be taken by Animals Committee) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.15 Eschrichtius robustus Gray Whale	JAPAN	Transfer Eastern North Pacific stock from App.I to App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 40 / 63, 6 abstentions)
Prop. 11.16 Balaenoptera acutorostrata Minke Whale	JAPAN	Transfer Southern Hemisphere stock from App.I to App.II	REJECTED as amended (trade only allowed between Parties with a DNA identification method in place) (VOTE 46 / 69, 4 abstentions)
Prop. 11.16 Balaenoptera acutorostrata Minke Whale	SURINAME	Amendment for 0 quota until CoP12	REJECTED (VOTE 47 / 66, 5 abstentions)
Prop. 11.17 Balaenoptera acutorostrata Minke Whale	JAPAN	Transfer Okhotsk Sea - West Pacific stock from App.I to App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 49 / 67, 3 abstentions)
Prop. 11.18 Balaenoptera acutorostrata Minke Whale	NORWAY	Transfer North-east Atlantic and North Atlantic Central stocks from App.I to App.II	REJECTED in Committee I (VOTE 52 / 57, 9 abstentions) and in Plenary as amended (to limit trade to animals taken within Norwegian waters, and only for trade to countries with DNA-based identification system) (VOTE 53 / 52, 8 abstentions)
Prop. 11.19 Parahyaenabrunnea Brown Hyena	NAMIBIA, SWITZERLAND	Delete from Appendix II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.20 Loxodonta africana; South African population African Elephant	SOUTH AFRICA	Transfer from App.I to App.II	ACCEPTED as amended (zero quota on trade in raw ivory) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.21 Loxodonta africana; Botswana population African Elephant	BOTSWANA	Maintain in App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.22 Loxodonta africana; Namibian population African Elephant	NAMIBIA	Maintain in App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.23 Loxodonta africana; Zimbabwean population African Elephant	ZIMBABWE	Maintain in App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.24 Loxodonta africana; Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe populations African Elephant	KENYA, INDIA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.25 Loxodonta africana African Elephant	SWITZERLAND	Amend App.II annotation re. Destination of live animals	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.26 Dugong dugon Dugong	AUSTRALIA	Transfer population of Australia from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED (VOTE BY SHOW OF HANDS)
Prop. 11.27 Vicugna vicugna Vicuña	BOLIVIA	Transfer all Bolivian populations that are in App.I to App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.28 Vicugna vicugna Vicuña	BOLIVIA	Delete zero quota for Bolivian populations that are in App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.29 Moschus spp. Musk Deer	INDIA, NEPAL, USA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.30 Ovis vignei Urial	GERMANY	Include in App.I all not listed subspecies	ACCEPTED as amended (all populations to App.II) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.31 Pterocnemia pennata pennata Darwin's Rhea	ARGENTINA	Transfer population of Argentina from App.I to App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.32 Falco rusticolus Gyrfalcon	USA	Transfer North American population from App.I to App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 35 / 31, 36 abstentions)
Prop. 11.33 Eunymphicus cornutus cornutus Horned Parakeet	FRANCE	Transfer from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.34 Eunymphicus cornutus uvaeensis Uvea Parakeet	FRANCE	Transfer from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.35 Garrulax canorus Melodious Laughing Thrush	CHINA	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED (VOTE 56 / 25)
Prop. 11.36 Cuora spp. Asian Box Turtle	GERMANY, USA	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.37 Clemmys guttata Spotted Turtle	USA	Include in App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 38 / 36, 31 abstentions)
Prop. 11.38 Geochelone sulcata African Spurred Turtoise	FRANCE	Transfer from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED as amended (zero quota for exports from the wild) (VOTE 73 / 17, 22 abstentions)
Prop. 11.39 Malacochersus tornieri Pancake Tortoise	KENYA, USA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN (after discussions between Kenya and Tanzania; TZ committed to not allow any exports from the wild)
Prop. 11.40 Eretmochelys imbricata Hawksbill Turtle	CUBA, DOMINICAN REPUBLIC	Transfer from App.I to App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.41 Eretmochelys imbricata Hawksbill Turtle	CUBA	Transfer from App.I to App.II	REJECTED in Committee I (VOTE 66 / 38, 15 abstentions) and in Plenary as amended (no trade until Standing Committee reviews control systems in Japan) (VOTE 67 / 41, 9 abstentions)
Prop. 11.42 Crocodylus morelettii Morelet's Crocodile	MEXICO	Transfer from App.I to App.II	WITHDRAWN before CoP
Prop. 11.43 Varanus melinus Quince Monitor	GERMANY	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.44 Crotalus horridus Timber Rattlesnake	USA	Include in App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.45 Bufo retiformis Sonoran green Toad	USA	Delete from App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.46 Mantella spp. Mantella Frogs	NETHERLANDS USA	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.47 Rhincodon typus Whale Shark	USA	Include in App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 51 / 40, 13 abstentions)
Prop. 11.48 Carcharodon carcharias Great white Shark	AUSTRALIA, USA	Include in App.I	REJECTED as amended (inclusion in Appendix II) (VOTE 51 / 47, 8 abstentions)
Prop. 11.49 Cetorhinus maximus Basking Shark	UNITED KINGDOM	Include in App.II	REJECTED in Committee I (VOTE 62 / 39, 6 abstentions) and in Plenary as amended (12-month delay in effective date for implementation) (VOTE 67 / 42, 8 abstentions)
Prop. 11.50 Latimeria spp. Coelacanths	FRANCE, GERMANY	Include in App.I	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.51 Latimeria menadoensis Coelacanth	INDONESIA	Include in App.I	WITHDRAWN (redundant following adoption of Prop. 11.50)
Prop. 11.52 Poecilotheria spp. Eastern Hemisphere Tarantulas	SRI LANKA, USA	Include in App.II	REJECTED (VOTE 49 / 30, 27 abstentions)
Prop. 11.53 Podophyllum hexandrum Rauvolfia serpentina Taxus wallichiana	SWITZERLAND	Annotation (harmonise exemptions for medicinal products)	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.54 Panax ginseng Asian Ginseng	RUSSIAN FEDERATION	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED as amended (same as annotation #3 > only roots subject to CITES for Russian populations only) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.55 Araucaria araucana Monkey puzzle tree	ARGENTINA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.56 Echinopsis Eulychnia Columnar cactus / Rainsticks	CHILE	Exempt 3 rainsticks	WITHDRAWN (with Resolution Conf.9.18 amended to exempt up to 3 rainsticks for personal use)
Prop. 11.57 Kalmia cuneata White Wicky	USA	Delete from App.II	ACCEPTED (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.58 Camptotheca acuminata Happy Tree	CHINA	Include in App.II	WITHDRAWN
Prop. 11.59 Cistanche deserticola Desert-living Cistanche	CHINA	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED as amended (same as annotation #3 > only roots subject to CITES) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.60 Harpagophytum procumbens, H.zeyheri Devil's claw	GERMANY	Include in App.II	WITHDRAWN (resolution adopted but Plants Committee will take same action based on Decision)
Prop. 11.61 Adonis vernalis Spring adonis	GERMANY	Include in App.II	ACCEPTED as amended (same as annotation #2) (CONSENSUS)
Prop. 11.62 Guaiacum sanctum Lignum vitae	USA	Transfer from App.II to App.I	WITHDRAWN (Action to be taken by Plants Committee)